IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2019 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE R. DEVDAS WRIT PETITION NO.47913/2016 (S-RES) BETWEEN :
Sri P. Venkatarayappa, S/o. Papanna, Aged about 48 years, R/o. @9/A, III Block, 10th Main, Near Muneshwara Temple, Nandini Layout, Bengaluru – 560 096.
Now serving as FDA, Welfare Department, BBMP, Dasarahalli Zone, Bengaluru -560 073.
... Petitioner (By Sri Satish M. Doddamani, Adv.) AND 1. The State of Karnataka Department of Urban, Vikasa soudha, Bengaluru-560001.
Represented by its Secretary.
2. The Commissioner Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike, N.R.Square, Bengaluru-560002.
3. The Special Commissioner (Administration) Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike, N.R.Square, Bengaluru-560002.
4. The Deputy Commissioner Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike, N.R.Square, Bengaluru-560002.
5. Smt. Suguna, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Office, Begur, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 083.
6. Smt. Shivamma V., Working as a Manager, Asst. Executive Engineer, BBMP, Bommanahalli Zone, Bengaluru – 560 068.
7. Sri D.S. Girish, Aged about 32 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer, BBMP, Bommanahalli Zone, Bengaluru – 560 068.
8. Sri N. Arun Kumar, Aged about 35 years, Asst. Revenue Office, Anjanapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 024.
9. Smt. Jothilakshmi S., Aged about 43 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Office, Arikere, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 076.
10. Sri K.S. Anand, Aged about 36 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Office, Yalichenahalli, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 078.
11. Sri Guruprasanna H.N., Aged about 40 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer, BBMP, South Zone, Bengaluru – 560 002.
12. Sri Narayanappa M., Aged about 42 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Executive Engineer, Arikere, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 076.
13. Sri S.V. Manjunath, Aged about 36 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Executive Engineer, BBMP, Uttharahalli, Bengaluru – 560 076.
14. Smt. Radha Cham Badigera, Aged about 34 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer, Town Plan, BBMP, South Zone, Bengaluru -560 002.
15. Sri Varun Kumar B., Aged about 36 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Office, Bommanahalli, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 068.
16. Sri G.S. Ramaprasad, Aged about 37 years, Working as a Mananger, Asst. Revenue Office, BTM Layout, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 076.
17. Smt. Rekha C., Aged about 29 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer, Vijayanagara, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 040.
18. Sri M.R. Ashok, Aged about 40 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Office, Shivajinagara, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 001.
19. Smt. Madhuri Kotagi, Aged about 37 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Officer, Shivajinagara, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 001.
20. Sri Naveen Kumar K., Aged about 31 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Officer, Sarvagna Nagar, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 002.
21. Smt. Shilpa N. Bharadwaj, Aged about 33 years, Working as a Manage, Horticulture Superintendent, South Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 002.
22. Sri D.K. Narasimha Murthy, Aged about 35 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Officer, HBR Layout, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 051.
23. Smt. Kruthika M.V., Aged abut 30 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Officer, C.V. Raman Nagar, West Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 038.
24. Sri Suresh H., Aged about 39 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Officer, Basavanagudi, South Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 004.
25. Smt. Jayashree M. Ambigera, Aged about 30 years, Working as a Manager, Admin, R.R. Nagar, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 098.
26. Smt. Kavitha M.Y., Aged about 40 years, Working as a Manager, C.E., RR Nagar, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 098.
27. Smt. Nagashree J., Aged about 30 years, Working as a Manager, Joint Commissioner Office, Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
28. Smt. G.K. Shobha, Aged about 37 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Officer, Yashwanthpura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 022.
29. Smt. Deepashree M.R., Aged about 36 years, Working as a Manager, C.E., SWD, Head Office, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 001.
30. Sri Srinivas Murthy N., Aged about 38 years, Working as a Manager, Secretary Council Office, Head Office, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 001.
31. Smt. K.S. Manjula, Aged about 35 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Revenue Office, West Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 86.
32. Smt. Nagaveni Erappa, Aged about 31 years, Working as a Manager, Joint Commissioner Office, South Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 002.
33. Smt. Deepa N.B., Aged about 31 years, Working as a Manager, Joint Commissioner Office, Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
34. Smt. Jaya B. Harithi Aged about 33 years, Working as a Manager, Health Office, Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
35. Smt. Rashmi K., Aged abpit 31 years, District Election Commissioner, North, Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
36. Ms. Safinaz, Aged about 38 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
37. Sri Mahesh Kadappa Savanth, Aged about 32 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, K.R. Puram, Mahadevapura Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 036.
38. Smt. Bhagyashree Halli, Aged about 32 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer, Chikkapete, BBMP West Zone, Bengaluru – 560 053.
39. Sri K.N. Yuvaraj Kumar, Aged about 34 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, Hoodi, Mahadevapura Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
40. Smt. Bharathi H., Aged about 33 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Officer, White Field, Mahadevapura Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
41. Sri H.V. Santhosh Kumar, Aged about 32 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, Marathahalli, Mahadevapura Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 048.
42. Smt. Suma C., Aged about 32 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer (Electrical), R.R. Nagar, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 098.
43. Smt. Chithra Lekha A., Aged about 31 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer, K.R. Puram, Mahadevapura Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 036.
44. Smt. K.C. Sumathi, Aged about 35 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, R.R. Nagar, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 098.
45. Smt. Nandini I/ Thasildara, Aged about 34 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, Laggere, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 058.
46. Smt. Vani B.E., Aged about 30 years, Working as a Manager, Revenue Office, Chandra Layout, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 040.
47. Sri K. Anand, Aged about 43 years, Working as a Manager, Executive Engineer (Electrical) South Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 002.
48. Sri Shivaputhra, Aged about 35 years, Working as a Manager, CE, Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 036.
49. Sri Bhagavanthappa, Aged about 32 years, Working as a Manager, Asst. Executive Engineer Mahadevapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 036.
50. Smt. Sharanamma, Aged about 41 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Srirampura, West Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 021.
51. Sri N. Ramesh, Aged about 38 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Gandhi Nagara, West Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 002.
52. Smt. Vasantha V., Aged about 40 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Chikkapete, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 053.
53. Sri Niranjan Murthy P., Aged about 40 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Chikkapete, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 053.
54. Sri N.G. Basavaraju, Aged about 40 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, J.P. Nagara, South Zone, BBMP, Bengalore – 560 078.
55. Sri A. V. Rajanna, Aged about 39 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Hoodi, Mahadevpura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 036.
56. Sri Adinath Chowgala, Aged about 39 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Thanisandra, Bytarayanapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 064.
57. Sri Chandrappa Birajjanavar, Aged about 40 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, K.R.Puram, Mahadevapura Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 036.
58. Sri Rajakumara, Aged about 37 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Mathikere, West Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 022.
59. Smt. B.N. Anitha, Aged about 31 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Anjanapura Ward, South Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 024.
60. Sri Indrajit Lamani, Aged about 32 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, Shivaji Nagara East Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 001.
61. Sri Janardhana Rajura, Aged about 48 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, HBR Layout, Bytarayanapura, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 064.
62. Sri Manjunatha, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, J.C. Nagar, South Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 006.
63. Sri A. Nallappa, Aged about 48 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, K.G.Halli, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 020.
64. Sri K. Shankar, Aged about 53 years, Working as a Assessor, Revenue Office, PIA, Dasarahalli Zone, BBMP, Bengaluru – 560 058. ….Respondents (By Sri T.P. Vivekananda, Adv. for C/R9, 8, 11, 35, 13, 16, 18, 22, 51, 52, 49, 57, 53, 55 and 58 Sri B.S. Goutham, Adv. for R2 to R4 Sri Sridhar, N.Hegde, HCGP for R1) This writ petition is filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India praying to quash the seniority list dated 09.09.2015 at Annexure-F only in so far the petitioner and private respondents are concerned and etc.
This writ petition coming on for Orders this day, the court made the following:
O R D E R R.DEVDAS J., (ORAL):
Learned counsel for the petitioner has filed a memo dated 14.02.2019 stating that during the pendency of the writ petitions, some of the respondents were transferred to various places. It is prayed by the petitioners that they may be permitted to withdraw the petition with liberty to file a fresh petition if necessary.
Accordingly, the petitions are dismissed as not pressed reserving liberty to the petitioner as prayed for.
SD/- JUDGE PN/-