IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 11TH DAY OF DECEMBER, 2017 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAGHVENDRA S. CHAUHAN WRIT PETITION NOS.20455-20492 OF 2013 (S-PRO) BETWEEN:
1. Shobha C D/o Sri K. S. Chandranathaiah Aged about 35 years AE, BESCOM, Corporate Office K R Circle, C.A Section Bengaluru-560001 Residing at #2-118/A 14th Cross Lakshminarayanapuram Bengaluru-560021 2. Jyothi Rani L. S D/o Sri L. Shankar Rao Aged about 32 years AE, BESCOM, Corporate Office K R Circle, C.A Section Bengaluru -560009 Residing at #434 14th "C" Cross, 2nd Stage 2nd Phase, Mahalakshmipuram Bengaluru -560086 3. Chennakeshavaiah S S/o. Sri Srinivasa Aged about 35 years AE, North Circle, BESCOM Bengaluru-560024 Residing at # D-16, KPTCL Officers Colony Quarters HAL, 2nd Stage, Indira Nagar Bengaluru-560038 4. Sandeepa U S/o Sri Ramaihandra Aged about 30 years AE, TCD(S) K.R.Circle Bengaluru-560009 Residing at # 3406 4th Cross, C Block Gayathri Nagar Bengaluru-560038 5. Jagadeesh H.R S/o Sri Ramegowda H.R Aged about 31 years AE, 66/11KV S/S KPTCL, Kunigal Residing at KEB Quarters # 10, Behind BESCOM Office Kunigal, Tumkur Dist-572130 6. Chandan L S/o Sri C. Lepanna Aged about 30 years AE, 66/11 KV Muss, KPTCL Melekote, Mandya District Residing at Nidagalte Hulikukunte, Post Sira Taluk, Tumkur Dist-572211 7. Asha Kotian D/o Sri Narasimha Kotian Aged about 29 years AE, Customer Relations BESCOM Corporate Office Bengaluru-560009 Residing at # 3, 6th Cross A.T Street, Vasanthnagar Bengaluru-560052 8. Venugopal K S/o Sri Keshavegowda A.J Aged about 34 years AE (Ele.), W-2 Sub-Division Shankarpura Residing at # 34, Shankarpura Main Road, Bengaluru-560004 9. Ramesh L S/o Sri B. Lingaiah Aged about 36 years AE(E), Agara unit S-11 S/D Residing at # 81, 7th E Main 3rd Stage, 2nd Block W.O.C. Road, Rajajinagara Bengaluru-560010 10. Maxwell M S/o Sri J. Michael Aged about 31 years AE, Works Unit, Rmy RSD Ramanagara BESCOM Residing at # 219/22 8th Main, 3rd Cross K.S.C, Bengaluru-560060 11. Kavitha K D/o Sri K.N. Kalasegowda Aged about 29 years AE, Projects, ICT & MIS Corporate Office, BESCOM K.R. Circle, Bengaluru-560009 Residing at #533, 15th Main Manjunathanagar W.O.C. Road Bengaluru-560010 12. Rajeshwari Gandhad D/o Sri Shrikantayya Gandhad Aged about 30 years AE, CGM (CA), Corporate Office BESCOM, KR Circle Bengaluru-560009 13. Shailaja D/o Sri Basangouda Patil Aged about 28 years AE, CGM (Operations) Corporate Office, BESCOM KR Circle, Bengaluru-560009 Residing at # 181, Manuvana Vijayanagar, Bengaluru-560040 14. Kalavathy S V D/o Sri S.K. Venkatachaval Aged about 29 years AE, BMAZ C2, BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 15. Rashmi M D/o Sri S. Mahadevappa Aged about 31 years AE, CGM (Operations) Corporate Office, BESCOM, KR Circle Bengaluru-560009 Residing at # 3397, Ratna Nilaya, 4th Cross Gayatri Nagar Bengaluru-560038 16. Ramesh P.N S/o Sri Ningappa Poojar Aged about 31 years AE, O&M 17, W5 S/D BESCOM, City Market Bengaluru Residing at #148, 5th Main I Phase, Manjunath Nagar Bengaluru-560038 17. N Manjunath S/o Sri M. Narayanamurthy Aged about 35 years AE, Major Works Bangalore BMWSD, K.R Circle Bengaluru-560009 Residing at # F-10, 11th Main 4th Cross, HAL 2nd Stage Bengaluru-560038 18. V Deepak S/o Sri Vishkante Gowda Aged about 31 years AE, Major Works Division Chamarajanagar Residing at #88/A2, B Main 2 B Cross,1st Cross Vijayanagar Mysore-570001 19. V Thippeswamy S/o. Sri. G.K Veerabhadraiah Aged about 29 years AE, 66/11 KV Muss B.G Kere Mulakalmure (T9) Residing at C/o Jaya Prakash Kendraly Mulakalmure-577585 20. Shalini S D/o Sri Sreedhar S Aged about 31 years AE, MT Division BMAZ Gavipuram Bengaluru-560004 Residing at # 123/2 7th Main, Hoskerehalli BSK 3rd Stage, Bengaluru-560078 21. Seema D/o Sri Subbarao Kulkarni Aged about 30 years JE, MT Division, BMAZ BESCOM, Residing at # 12 A, 12th Cross 2nd Main, Vittalnagar Bengaluru-560015 22. Vaishali B.S D/o Sri Shankara D.K Aged about 28 years AE (T), C4 Sub Division BESCOM, Bengaluru Residing at #203, I Floor 24th Main, 23rd Cross Judicial Layout, Yelahanka Bengaluru-560064 23. R. Prathibha D/o Sri K. Rangappa Aged about 28 years AE(T), C8 Sub Dvn, BESCOM, Bengaluru Residing at # 663 Ajmallappa Layout Kacharacharalli Bengaluru-560082 24. Venkatesh Sagar S/o Sri Siddappa Aged about 34 years AE (E), Unit-W3 Sub-Div. BESCOM, Bengaluru Residing at #16, 16th A Cross Sri Ramanagar, Bengaluru-560042 25. Manjunath G S/o Sri N. S. Govindaraju Aged about 30 years AE, RT-Lab S/D Mysore KPTCL Residing at # 365, 8th Cross 7th Main, K C Layout Mysore-570001 26. Radhika P D/o Sri Purushotham Aged about 32 years AE, Hebbal Division BESCOM, Bengaluru Residing at #42 Flat Opp Tatanagar, Kodigehalli Main Road, Bengaluru-560092 27. Abhijatha S/o Sri K.K. Hamsavathy Aged about 29 years AE, SLDC, KPTCL Anand Rao Circle Bengaluru-560009 Residing at No.165/1353 Sudha Nilaya, Rekha Falm JP Nagar, Bengaluru-560078 28. Indira J D/o Sri Jagadiesh D Aged about 29 years AE, SLDC, KPTCL Anand Rao Circle Bengaluru Residing at # 27, RMV 2nd Stage, Krishnappa Layout, Sanjaynagar Bengaluru-560094 29. Anand Kumar G.J S/o Y.D Jayamma Aged about 33 years AE, BESCOM, AE Channapatna Residing at 15/A, 2nd Main Renukambanagar Road Channapatna-562117 30. Chandrashekara M S/o Sri Manachari K Aged about 35 years I/C AE, BESCOM, AE & M OSD CP6 Residing at # 46 Main Road 1st Floor, KEFB Colony Mandya-571404 31. Nuzarth A S/o Sri T.M Abdulla Aged about 34 years AE, O/o EE, M7 DM # 537, VSR Sabhayana Gavipuram, Basavangudi Bengaluru-560004 Residing at # 28, 2nd Cross SBM Colony Brindavanagar Mathikere, Bengaluru-560054 32. Geeta V. Madivaler D/o Sri V.Y. Madivalar Aged about 32 years AE, O/o EE, C, O & M Rajajinagar Dvn., BESCOM Bengaluru-560010 Residing at # 1523, 15th Main MC Layout, Vijayanagar Bengaluru-560040 33. Merin Ninan S/o Sri Ninan Daniel Aged about 31 years AE, PCKL, Cauvery Bhavan Bengaluru-560009 Residing at # 91/A Venkateshwara Colony New Tippasandra Bengaluru-560075 34. Shashidhar Reddy J Office Address: AE, BESCOM Sahakar Nagar Bengaluru-560098 35. Srikanth S.S AE, BESCOM, Shanthinagar S-2, Sub Division Bengaluru-560027 36. Mamatha MPD, BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 37. Manasa S MPD, BESCOM, Bengaluru-560009 38. Hafizunnisa M HSR Division BESCOM, HSR Layout Bengaluru-560102 (By Sri. M. Nagaprasanna, Advocate) AND:
1. State of Karnataka Represented by its Principal Secretary to Govt. of Karnataka Energy Department Vikas Soudha Dr.B.R. Ambedkar Veedhi Bengaluru-560001 2. The Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited Cauvery Bhavan K.G. Road Bengaluru-560009 Represented by its Managing Director ... Petitioners 3. The Director (Admin and Human Resources) Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited Cauvery Bhavan, K.G. Road Bengaluru-560009 4. Pavithra K Pin No. 14694 TCD, KPTCL Bengaluru-560009 5. Suresh Kumar M Pin No: 14701 HT Rating Works Circle CESCO, Mysuru-570001 6. Anand C Pin No. 14707 TCD, KPTCL Bengaluru-560009 7. Vasanthkumar Rathod Pin No: 14719 O & M Zone HESCOM, Hubli-580028 8. Srinivas H.R Pin No. 14739 O & M2 City Sub-Division Tumkur-572221 9. Sushma R Pin No. 14745 TCD, KPTCL Bengaluru-560009 10. Rajashekar R Pin No. 14750 Major Works Division KPTCL, Raichur-583260 11. Abhilash Pin No : 14755 O & M Division Tumkur-572221 12. Nagaraj T Pin No. 14784 MT Sub-Division, BESCOM Chikkaballapura-562101 13. Geetha Bankadamani Pin No: 14786 220 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL Gadag-582101 14. Umesh Pin No: 14787 110, KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL, Sasthapura, Gulbarga-585321 15. Kalakappa Pin No.14790 O & M Sub-Division Deodurga Gulbarga-585321 16. Palakshi P Halanaikar Pin No. 14803 O & M Division MESCOM, Shimoga-577201 17. Ashwini D.V Pin No. 14804 O & M E-6 Sub-Division BESCOM, Bengaluru-560009 18. Manjunatha P Bokhi Pin No. 14810 O & M 2 Sub-Division HESCOM Mahalingapura-587312 19. Krishnamurthy B.R Pin No. 14814 110 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL Navanagara Hubli-580025 20. Nagaraj H. Chithapathy Pin No: 14816 110 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL Kadankoppa-580005 21. Rajanikanth Hamani Pin No. 14817 220 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL Ambevadi-581383 22. Manju N Pin No. 14822 Customer Relations, BESCOM Corporate Office, K.R. Circle Bengaluru-560009 23. Shashidhar J.M Pin No. 14824 Vigilance, Works Circle CESCO, Mysuru-570001 24. Dhanyakumar H.C Pin No. 14829 66 KV Sub-Station, KPTCL Oordigere Tumkur-572211 25. Vajrakumar H.D Pin No. 14832 O & M Division CESCO, Arasikere-583125 26. Sudhirkumar D Pin No. 14840 66 KV Sub Station, KPTCL Athigere Davanagere-583131 27. Gopinath K.L Pin No.14841 O & M N-4, Sub-Division BESCOM, Bengaluru-560009 28. Chandrakanth D. Nayak Pin No. 14853 TC Sub-Division, KPTCL Munirabad-583234 29. Thirupathi Kamathar Pin No. 14854 220 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL Kustagi-584121 30. Aravindkumar L Naik Pin No. 14857 O & M City Sub-Division HESCOM, Bagalkote-587301 31. Purshotham Kattimani Pin No: 14859 HT Rating Works Sub-Division GESCOM, Bellary-583226 32. Rani S. Lokare Pin No. 14866 RT Division, KPTCL Belagaum-590001 33. Jyothi S Pin No: 14867 TL & SS Division, KPTCL Hubli-580025 34. Lokesh K.S Pin No: 14869 MIS, Corporate Office CESCO, Mysuru-570001 35. Varsha Chawan Pin No: 14872 220 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL, NRS Shimoga-577201 36. Srikanth S Pin No: 14873 110 KV Power Distribution Station, KPTCL Talaguppa-577430 37. Mahesh H Pin No: 14875 HT Rating Division MESCOM, Udupi-576103 38. Rajesh D Pin No: 14876 220 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL, NRS Antharasanahalli-572211 39. Yogesh R.M Pin No: 14877 O & M S-7, Sub Division BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 40. Rajeswari K Pin No: 14890 400 KV Power Receiving Station, KPTCL, NRS Nelamangala-562123 41. Sunil Kumar A Pin No: 14892 O & M Jappu Section Office Division, MESCOM Mangalore-575001 42. Madhusudhan R Pin No: 14899 O & M Division, BESCOM Chitradurga-577585 43. Prasannakumar D.S Pin No: 14900 220 KV Power Receiving Station KPTCL, NRS Yerrandahalli-560009 44. Nandeesh M.S Pin No. 14901 MPD, KPTCL CESCO, Mysuru-570001 45. Rajkumar Naik B Pin No: 14903 R & D , Corporate Office KPTCL, KR Circle Bengaluru-560009 46. Bramaramba M Pin No: 14904 O & M Kollegal Division CESCO, Kollegal-571439 47. Gayathri T Pin No: 14906 Corporate Office, BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 48. Hemanth Ghodkhe Pin No: 14908 Corporate Office, HESCOM Hubli-580025 49. Pundaleeka Ghokale Pin No: 14910 O & M Division GESCOM, Bidar-585401 50. Anasuaya S. Lamani Pin No: 14917 O & M Division, Chandapura BESCOM, Chandapura-562145 51. Manjula V. Rao Pin No: 14918 LT Rating-1 CESCO, Mysuru-570001 52. Mallanna V Pin No: 14920 O & M Division CESCO, Periyapatna-571102 53. Anitha Y.S Pin No: 14921 TL & SS Division, KPTCL Peenya, Bengaluru-560046 54. Yashwanth Nayak Y Pin No: 14924 O & M City-1 Sub Division MESCOM, Shimoga-577201 55. H. Girish Naik Pin No: 14926 O & M Sub-Division GESCOM, Hadagali-583235 56. Nagarajappa C Pin No: 14929 O & M Sub-Division HESCOM, Sirasi-581413 57. Sushma M.S Pin No: 14931 O & M Rural Sub-Division BESCOM, Kanakapura-562167 58. Srinivasmurthy B.T Pin No: 14956 Major Works (North) Division, KPTCL Bengaluru-560009 59. Kohith Kumar K Pin No: 14957 O & M Division, BESCOM Harihara-577601 60. Girish S.K Pin No: 14959 O & M City Sub-Division BESCOM, Chikkanayakanahalli-572214 61. Srinivasmurthy B Pin No: 14972 Corporate Office, BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 62. Nagaraj D. Yalkar Pin No: 14974 O & M Bailahongala Division, HESCOM Bailahongala-591102 63. Nandeesh C.P Pin No: 14979 Corporate Office, BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 64. Anitha K Pin No: 14999 O & M Sub-Division, BESCOM KGF-563101 65. Nagbhushan C Pin No: 15007 220 KV Power Receiving Station KPTCL Honnali-577217 66. Gurubasavaraju N.M Pin No: 15008 O & M Circle, BESCOM Davanagere-583131 67. Chandramouli R.T Pin No: 15013 66 KV Sub-Station, KPTCL Pandavapura-571434 68. Anilkumar J Pin No: 15016 O & M Sub-Division CESCO, Hootagalli Mysuru-570001 69. Umesh Kumar K.A Pin No. 15017 O & M Sub-Division GESCOM, Hospet-583201 70. Jyothi T.M Pin No: 15078 O & M Division MESCOM, Sagar-577401 71. Chandukumar K Pin No: 15019 66 KV Sub-Station, KPTCL Suthuru, Hootagalli Mysuru-570001 72. Maralasiddappa M.R Pin No: 15020 220 KV Power Receiving Station KPTCL, Lingapura-583234 73. Kumar V.H Pin No: 15024 110 KV Power Distribution Station, KPTCL Bykampadi Mangalore-575010 74. Puttaswamy D.V Pin No: 15032 O & M E-1 Sub-Division, BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 75. Annapurna R Pin No: 15034 Major Works Division KPTCL Davanagere-583131 76. Sanjiv Kumar Pin No: 15037 O & M Gulbarga Sub-Division GESCOM, Gulbarga-585301 77. Sandhya C Mirazkar Pin No: 15043 PLC, KPTCL Davanagere-577002 78. Somanna H Pin No: 15050 220 KV Power Receiving Station KPTCL Davanagere-577002 79. Arathi C Pin No: 15053 220 KV Power Receiving Station KPTCL Kadkola-577005 80. Jyothi M.G Pin No: 15058 O & M N-7 Sub-Division BESCOM Bengaluru-560009 81. Ravikumar K Pin No: 15063 O & M Chikkamagalur Sub-Division MESCOM Chikmagalur-577126 82. Gopal R Pin No: 15064 O & M City-2 Sub-Division MESCOM, Shimoga-577201 83. Lingam Arunkumar Pin No: 15068 O & M, Works Unit Sub-Division GESCOM, Koppal-583235 84. Yashoda M Pin No: 15070 66 KV Sub-Station KPTCL, KHB Colony-560023 85. Chandramma S.P Pin No: 15075 O & M Hassan-1 Sub-Division CESCO, Hassan-573213 86. Harish S Pin No: 15076 O & M City-1 Sub-Division MESCOM, Shimoga-577201 ... Respondents (By Sri. Venkatesh H. Dodderi, AGA for R-1;
Sri. Joseph Anthony for JSM Law Partners for R-2 & R-3; Sri. Vikas Rojipura, Advocate for R-4 to R-86) These writ petitions are filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying to quash the impugned order dated 02.05.2013 vide Annexure-A issued by the R3 in so far as R4 to R86 are concerned.
These writ petitions coming on for Final Hearing, this day, the Court made the following:
ORDER Mr. M. Nagaprasanna, the learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that these petitions have become infructuous.
Therefore, these petitions are hereby dismissed as infructuous.
Sd/- JUDGE Mds/-