IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 26TH DAY OF APRIL, 2019 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SREENIVAS HARISH KUMAR REGULAR FIRST APPEAL No.819 OF 2019 BETWEEN:
Smt. Savithramma, Since dead by LRs., 1. A.Chirag, S/o. K.V.Anand Kumar, Aged about 18 years, 2. A.Rahul, S/o. K.V.Anand Kumar, aged about 15 years, Appellant No.2 is a Minor, He is represented by Next friend Mother and Executer under the will, Smt. B.B.Geetharani, W/o. K.V.Anand Kumar, Aged about 36 years, R/A Sir. M.V.Layout, M.G.Road Cross, Chikkaballapura-562101.
(By Sri. Satish, Advocate) …Appellants AND:
Bhagavath Prasad, S/o. Late A.Venkatanarasimhaiah, Since dead by LRs., 1. Smt. V.Shylaja, W/o. Late K.V.Bhagavath Prasad, Aged about 52 years, R/at No.83, T.G.Tank Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
2. B. Krishnaveni, D/o. Late K.V.Bhagavath Prasad, Aged about 18 years, C/o. V.Shylaja, No.83, T.G.Tank Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
3. K.V.Anand Kumar, S/o. Late A.Venkatanarasimhaiah, Aged about 47 years, R/at Sir M.V. Layout, M.G.Road Cross, Chikkaballapura-562101.
4. Sri. K.A.Lokesh Murthy S/o. Anjinappa, Aged about 68 years, R/at Kondenahalli Village, Chikkaballapura-562101.
5. Sri. Doddapillappa, S/o. Apponu @ Venkataswamy, Aged about 84 years, R/at No.428, Kandavarpet, Chikkaballapura-562101.
A.Ramaiah, S/o. Mitay Annayappa, Since dead by LRs, 6. Ravi, S/o. A.Ramaiah, Aged about 56 years, R/at 3rd Cross, Old Canara Bank Road, Chamarajpete, Chikkaballapura-562101.
7. Murali, S/o. A.Ramaiah, Aged about 53 years, R/at 3rd Cross, Old Canara Bank Road, Chamarajpete, Chikkaballapura-562101.
8. Anuradha, W/o. Late Raju, Aged about 51 years, 9. Sheethal, D/o. Late Raju, Aged about 32 years, 10. Archana, D/o. Late Raju, Aged about 30 years, Respondent No.8 to 10 are R/at 3rd Cross, Old Canara Bank Road, Chamarajpete, Chikkaballapura-562101.
11. Vasantha, D/o. Late Raju, Aged about 51 years, R/at 3rd Cross, Old Canara Bank Road, Chamarajpete, Chikkaballapura-562101.
12. Sri. Somashekar, S/o. Chikkaveeranna, Aged about 61 years, R/at No.1321, Madhuri, Veerabhadraswamy Krupa, Behind Government First Grade College, Chikkaballapura-562101.
13. Smt. M.S.Gayathridevi, W/o. Somashekar, Aged about 61 years, R/at No.1321, Madhuri Veerabhadraswamy Krupa, Behind Government First Grade College, Chikkaballapura-562101.
14. Smt. B.M.Prema Kumari, W/o. C.R.Jagadeeshwar, Aged about 57 years, C/o. Jagadeesh Medicals, R/at 2nd Nagarathpete, Shidlaghatta Town, Chikkaballapura-562101.
15. Sri. Lakshmi Narayanappa, S/o. Siddalingappa, Aged about 64 years, R/at No.576, Behind Vani Talkies, Chickballapura Town-562101.
16. Smt. T.S.Hemalatha, W/o. R.Venkatesh, Aged about 50 years, R/at C/o. Rani Garments, B.B.Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
17. Smt. K.V.Subhashini, W/o. T.S.Sridhar, Aged about 38 years, R/at No.404, Koramarapet, Chikkaballapura-562101.
18. Sri. H.K.Srinivas Murthy, S/o. H.G.Keshavan, Aged about 60 years, Above Sri. Lakshmi Cement Agencies, Beside Byraveshwara Financiers, M.G.Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
19. Sri. C.N.Chandranna, S/o. Nanjappa, aged about 58 years, High School Teacher, Behind Basaveshwara Kalyana Mantap, Belliyappa Building, Hassan-573201.
20. Sri. I.P.Shivarama Prasad, S/o. Iyatha Pattaabhiramaiah Shetty, Aged about 51 years, R/at No.43, Behind Kannikaparameshwari Temple, Chikkaballapura-562101.
21. Kumari Ramarathna, D/o. D.C.Papanna, Teacher Convent School, Aged about 59 years, R/at 3rd Division, Kharkhanpet, N.P.O.Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
22. Sri. D.P.Ramakrishna, S/o. D.C.Papanna, Aged about 72 years, R/at 3rd Division, Kharkhanpet, N.P.O.Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
23. Smt. K.R.Indumathi, W/o. Late Ramanagarada Nagaraj, Aged about 53 years, R/at Bhuvan College Compound, Venkatala, Yalahanka, Bengaluru-560064.
24. Sri. M.Lakshman Das, S/o. M.Muniswamappa, Aged about 63 years, KSRTC Mechanic, R/at 639, Opposite Neela Krishnappa’s Shop, Valasanna Street, Kandavarapet, Chikkaballapura-562101.
25. Smt. A.N.Geetha, W/o. K.V.Lava Kumar, Aged about 54 years, R/at Opposite BCM Girls Hostel, Near Prashanthi Balamandira, North Extension, Chikkaballapura-562101.
26. Kumari. M.Vidyashree, D/o. G.M.Manjunath, Aged about 29 years, R/at 173, Cotton Pet Main Road, Cottonpet, Bengaluru-560053.
27. Smt. K.V.Lalitha, W/o. G.M.Manjunath, Aged about 48 years, R/at 173, Cotton Pet Main Road, Cottonpet, Bengaluru-560053.
28. Sri. K.R.Dwarakanath, S/o. K.Ramachar, Aged about 64 years, R/at 9/A, Railway Quarters, PWD Colony, Mysore City-560023.
29. Smt. C.Lakshmi, W/o. V.Shekhar, Aged about 42 years, R/at 175, 9th Cross, 2nd Main, Bakshi Garden, Bengaluru City-560053.
30. B.Devaraj, S/o. Late Bachappa, Aged about 57 years, R/at Cheedachikkanahalli Village, Nandi Hobli, Chikkaballapura Taluk, Chikkaballapura-562101.
31. Sri. B.Narayanappa, S/o. Veerappa, Aged about 71 years, R/at Bannikuppe Village, Agalagurike Post, Nandi Hobli, Chickballapura Taluk, Chikkaballapura-562101.
32. Sri. B.M.Munireddy, S/o. Munegowda, aged about 37 years, R/at Adavi Gollavarihalli Village, Ramadevaragudi Post, Kasaba Hobli, Chickballapura Taluk, Chikkaballapura-562101.
33. Sri. S.H.Suresh, S/o. H.P.Srinivasa Murthy, Aged about 51 years, R/at 68, 5th Cross, 2nd Main, Sowdamini Badavane, Konanakunte, Bengaluru-560052.
34. Sri. K.A.Shamanna, S/o. Appaiah, aged about 63 years, R/at Neeladri Nilaya, Muncipal Layout, M.G.Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
35. Sri. K.Munikrishnappa, S/o. Kempanna, aged about 56 years, R/at Cheedachikkanahalli Village, Nandi Hobli, Chickballapura Taluk, Chikkaballapura-562101.
36. Sri. M.Narayanaswamy, S/o. Munishamappa, aged about 45 years, R/at Agalagurike Post, Nandi Hobli, Chickballapura Taluk, Chikkaballapura-562101.
37. Sri. Lakshmikanthachari, S/o. Late Krishnachari, Aged about 63 years, Administrative Section, Kumara Krupa Guest House, High Grounds, Bengaluru-560001.
38. Smt. H.M.Munirathanamma, W/o. M.Munikrishna, Aged about 55 years, R/at No.37, 8th G Street, Ulsoor, Jowgupalya, Bengaluru-560008.
39. Smt. K.Suvarnamala, W/o. K.Saibaba, Aged about 68 years, R/at Markapuram Zilla, Parishath Girl High School, Markapuram, Prakasham District, Andra Pradesh—523316.
40. Sri. S.P.Shivanna, S/o. Pillappa, aged about 47 years, R/at Seekayanahalli Village, Kundana Hobli, Vishwanathapuram Post, Devanahalli Taluk, Bengaluru Rural District-562110.
41. Sri. Ashwatha Narayan, S/o. Chikka Kariyappa, Aged about 54 years, R/at Somenahalli Village, Gudibanda Taluk, Chikkaballapura-561209.
42. Smt. Shantha Erappa, S/o. B.Erappa KAS, Aged about 63 years, R/at 1st Cross, Lakshminarasimhanilaya, Someshwara Extension, Tumakuru-572102.
43. Sri. R.Ramachandraiah, S/o. Annayappa, aged about 55 years, R/at 663, Old Canara Bank Road, Chamrajapet, Chikkaballapura-562101.
44. Smt. Sai Kumari, W/o. K.Sathya Shankar, Aged about 55 years, C/o. Markapuram Zilla, Parishath Girls High School, Markapuram, Prakasham District, Andra Pradesh-523316.
45. sri. M.Mariswamy, S/o. Muniyappa, Aged about 52 years, Dharmachatra Road, Chikkaballapura-562101.
46. Sri. R.Chandrappa, S/o. Late G.Rudrappa, Aged about 47 years, R/at Dairy Narayaswamy House Road, Vapasandra, Chikkaballapura-562101.
... Respondents This RFA filed under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of CPC against the judgment and decree dated 19.01.2019 passed in O.S.No.121/2007 on the file of the II Additional Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Chickballapur dismissing the suit for partition and separate possession.
This RFA coming on for orders this day, the Court made the following:
ORDER The valuation slip shows that the valuation of the plaintiff’s share is Rs.4,80,000/-. Therefore this appeal is not maintainable in the High Court. Registry is directed to return the appeal papers along with certified copy of the impugned judgment to the appellant enabling her to re- present the same before the concerned District Court within 60 days from today.
Sd/- JUDGE KMV/-