IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF MARCH, 2019 BEFORE BETWEEN:
THE HON' BLE MR. JUSTICE B. VEERAPPA WRIT PETITION No.22941/2018(GM-CPC) 1. SMT. JAYAMMA, D/O LATE H. M. HANUMA REDDY AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS R/A 3RD CROSS, 2ND MAIN, CHINNAPANAHALLI VILLAGE MARATHAHALLI POST BENGALURU - 560037 REP BY HER POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER SMT. H G LAKSHMI W/O SRI P DHANARAJ AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS NO 2,1ST MAIN, 4TH FLOOR, SEVEN HILLS, SATISH NILAYA, TALAKAVERI LAYOUT, AMRUTHAHALLI VILLAGE BENGALURU – 560092.
... PETITIONER (BY SRI G. S. VENKAT SUBBARAO, ADVOCATE) AND 1. H THIPPA REDDY S/O LATE H M HANUMA REDDY 69 YERAS SAIKRUPA CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST, BANGALORE – 560037.
2. R SATHYANARAYANA REDDY S/O LATE H M HANUMA REDDY 66 YEARS R/O CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE – 560037.
3. VENKATESH REDDY S/O LATE H M HANUMA REDDY 59 YEARS R/O CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE - 560037 4. SRI ANANTH RAM REDDY SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS a) SMT. SUMA REDDY D/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY AND SMT NAGAVENI, 24 YEARS b) SMT. A SOWMYA REDDY, D/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY AND SMT NAGAVENI 22 YEARS c) SMT. DEENA W/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY 42 YEARS d) SRI CA. C SANDEEP REDDY S/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY AND SMT. DEENA M 21 YEARS 4(a) TO (d) ARE R/O CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE – 560037.
5. SMT. N. K. NAGAVENI D/O LATE SHARADAMMA, 46 YEARS R/O CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE - 560037 6. SMT. N K JAYANTHI D/O LATE SHARADAMMA 36 YEARS DODDANEKKUNDI POST, BENGALURU-560037.
7. SRI N K VASUDEV REDDY S/O LATE SHARADAMMA 55 YEARS NO 99, MAHESHWARI NILAYA DODDANEKKUNDI POST, BANGALORE - 560037 8. SRI N K BABU REDDY S/O LATE SHARADAMMA 39 YEARS, NO 99, MAHESHWARI NILAYA DODDANEKKUNDI POST, BANGALORE - 560037 9. SMT. N K KAMALAKSHAMMA D/O LATE SHARADAMMA 57 YEARS 10. SMT N K SUDHA D/O LATE SHARADAMMA 52 YEARS 11. SMT N K GOWRAMMA D/O LATE SHARADAMMA 49 YEARS 9 TO 11 ARE R/O HOODI POST HOODI, BANGALORE – 560037.
12. SMT. N K LAKSHMI D/O LATE SHARADAMMA 44 YEARS DODDANEKKUNDI POST BANGALORE – 560037.
13. SMT. N K MANU D/O LATE SHARADAMMA 42 YEARS DODDANEKKUNDI POST BANGALORE - 560037 14. SRI P BABU S/O LATE VIJAYAMMA 39 YEARS ANANTHARAM REDDY LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI POST, CHINNAPANAHALLI BANGALORE - 560037 15. SMT P GAYATHRI D/O LATE VIJAYAMMA 36 YEARS ANANTHARAM REDDY LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI POST, CHINNAPANAHALLI, BANGALORE - 560037 16. SRI P NATARAJ S/O LATE VIJAYAMMA 45 YEARS ANANTHARAM REDDY LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI POST, CHINNAPANAHALLI, BANGALORE - 560037 17. SRI P LAKSHMINARAYAN REDDY S/O LATE PEDHAKKA,64 YEARS NO 13, CHINNAPANAHALLI, DODDANEKKUNDI POST, BANGALORE - 560037 18. SMT P NAGAMMA D/O LATE SAVITHRAMMA C/O NAGARAJ, 49 YEARS ANANTHARAM REDDY LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI POST, CHINNAPANAHALLI BANGALORE - 560037 19. SMT. P CHANDRA D/O LATE SAVITHRAMMA C/O NAGARAJ, 47 YEARS ANANTHARAM REDDY LAYOUT MARATHAHALLI POST, CHINNAPANAHALLI BANGALORE - 560037 20. SMT SUMA REDDY D/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY AND SMT N K NAGAVENI 28 YEARS CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST, BANGALORE - 560037 21. SMT A SOWMYA REDDY D/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY AND SMT N K NAGAVENI 26 YEARS CHINNAPANAHALLI, MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE – 560037.
22. SMT. M DEENA W/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY 46 YEARS CHINNAPANAHALLI MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE - 560037 23. SRI A SANDEEP REDDY S/O LATE ANANTHARAM REDDY AND SMT. M DEENA 25 YEARS CHINNAPANAHALLI, MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE - 560037 24. SRI L V RAJU S/O LATE R L RAJU, 68 YEARS R/A NO 76 RANGA RAO ROAD SHANKARAPURAM BANGALORE - 560004 25. SMT. N A HEMAVATHY D/O N H ANANTHA REDDY MAJOR 26. SMT. N A NALINA D/O N H ANANTHA REDDY MAJOR 27. SMT. N A KAVITHA D/O N H ANANTHA REDDY MAJOR 25 TO 27 ARE R/A NO 668, 14TH CROSS, 13TH MAIN ROAD, 2ND PHASE, J P NAGAR BANGALORE – 560076.
28. SRI S NAGENDRA BABU S/O H SATHYANARAYANA REDDY MAJOR R/A HANUMAREDDY LAYOUT CHINNAPPANAHALLI DODDANEKUNDI POST, BANGALORE – 560037.
29. SRI T. VIJAYA KUMAR @ VIJAYA BABU S/O H. THIPPA REDDY MAJOR, R/A SAI KRUPA HANUMA REDDY LAYOUT CHINNAPPANAHALLI DODDANEKKUNDI POST, BANGALORE - 560037 30. SRI G V CHANDRASHEKAR S/O G R VENKATASWAMY REDDY, MAJOR, R/O GUNJUR GRAMA VARTHUR POST, BANGALORE - 560087 31. M/S ROHAN ASSOCIATES PRADEEP CHAMBERS 813, BHANDARKAR INSTITUTE ROAD, PUNE – 411004.
REP BY ITS PARTNER MR SANJAY KUSHALCHAND LUNKAD ALSO AT M/S ROHAN ASSOCIATES, NO 1201, 1ST FLOOR, DIVYA SHAKTI, 100’ ROAD, INDIRANAGAR, BANGALORE - 560038 32. SRI SANJAY KUSHALCHJAND LUNKAD PARTNER M/S ROHAN ASSOCIATES NO 1201, 1ST FLOOR, DIVYA SHAKTI, 100’ ROAD, INDIRANAGAR BANGALORE - 560038 33. M/S GOODRICH AEROSPACE SERVICES PVT LTD SY NO 14/1 AND 15/1 MARUTHI INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PHASE- II HOODI VILLAGE WHITEFIELD, K. R. PURAM HOBLI, BANGALORE – 560048.
REP. BY ITS VICE PRESIDENT MR. CHRISTOPHER ANIL RAO 34. G V LAKSHMIKANTH RAJU S/O M G VASANTHAIAH AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS R/AT NO 9/1 28TH CROSS, KILLARI ROAD, BANGALORE – 560003.
35. SMT. VANAMALA, D/O H HANUMA REDDY W/O LATE RAMACHANDRA REDDY 52 YEARS, CHINNAPANAHALLI, MARATHAHALLI BANGALORE - 560037 36. SMT SARASAMMA D/O H. HANUMA REDDY W/O LATE RAMACHADRA REDDY 62 YEARS RESIDING AT KOLAR - 563101 NEAR RTO OFFICE 37. SRI A. ANNADANAPPA S/O LATE R A SAGANABASAPPA, MAJOR, R/A NEW THIPPASANDRA BANGALORE – 560075.
38. SRI K ASHWATH S/O SRI S KRISHNAPPA MAJOR, C/O MUNITHAYAPPA BUILDING HOODI VILLAGE BANGALORE - 560048 39. SRI H B SUDHIR S/O H S BASAVARAJAPPA 42 YEARS R/A NO 33, BASAVA KRUPA NANDIDURG ROAD, JAYAMAHAL, BANGALORE - 560046 40. SRI N. SRINVASA REDDY S/O LATE T. NARAYANA REDDY 63 YEARS, R/A NO 89, 4TH CROSS, GOKULA 3RD STAGE MYSORE – 570002.
41. SRI N THIMMA REDDY S/O LATE T NARAYANA REDDY 60 YEARS R/A NO 57, 4TH MAIN, DOMLUR 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE - 560071 42. SRI N GOPAL REDDY S/O LATE T NARAYAN REDDY 53 YEARS, R /A NO 2, MUTHASANDRA VIA VARTHUR BANGALORE - 560087 43. SRI P VENKATESHWARA RAO S/O SRI P SURANNA 49 YEARS R/A NO 384/A, SINDURA APARTMENTS, RMV II STAGE, II BLOCK, BANGALORE – 560094.
44. SRI G K SURESH S/O G T KRISHNAPPA REDDY 41 YEARS R/O GUNJUR VILLAGE VARTHUR BANGALORE - 560087 45. M/S VIJETHA CONSTRUCTIONS A PARTNERSHIP FIRM NO 13/2, OPP : PRESTIGE OZONE, WHITEFIELD BANGALORE – 560066. REP. BY ITS PARTNER SRI B SREEDHAR.
46. SMT KAMALAMMA W/O SRI H. THIPPA REDDY R/A NO 22, SAI KRUPA CHINNAPANAHALLI, MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE - 560037 47. SRI T MURALIDHAR S/O SRI H. THIPPA REDDY R/A NO 23, R J GARDEN I CROSS, ANANTH NAGAR, CHINNAPANAHALLI, MARATHAHALLI POST BANGALORE – 560037.
48. SRI T. KIRAN KUMAR S/O SRI H. THIPPA REDDY R/A NO 1/6, RAJ PALYA, HOODI VILLAGE, K R PURAM HOBLI, BANGALORE - 560048 49. MAHAVEER PROPERTIES MHAVEER BOWER - II REP BY ITS PROP:
SRI P SATHYA SHEKAR NO 1, MAHAVEER TOWERS 3RD FLOOR, 24TH MAIN, J P NAGAR 5TH PHASE, BANGALORE – 560078.
50. SRI RAJEEV KUMAR GUPTHA FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN TO THE PLAINTIFF MAJOR R/A FLAT NO 301, 2ND FLOOR 51. SMT. NIDHI GUPTHA W/O SRI RAJEEV KUMAR GUPTHA MAJOR R/A FLAT NO 301, 2ND FLOOR 52. DR. HIREMATH VAMADEVAIAH S/O SRI H. M. PANCHAKSHARAIAH MAJOR R/A FLAT NO. 404, 4TH FLOOR, 53. SRI T. SUNIL KUMAR, S/O SRI T. PRASAD 34 YEARS 54. SMT. T. N. L. SHILPA, W/O SRI T SUNIL KUMAR MAJOR R/A NO 203, 2ND FLOOR 55. SRI K. MOHAN DAS S/O SRI D. KRISHNA VADIYAR ,60 YEARS R/A NO 402, 4TH FLOOR, 56. SRI AMITHAVA PAUL S/O SRI BABU PAUL, 32 YEARS R/A NO 402, 4TH FLOOR, 57. SRI R. PADMANABHAN S/O SRI S. RAJAGOPAL, 38 YEARS R/A FLAT NO 102, 1ST FLOOR, 58. SRI A. K. RAMANJALU S/O LATE SRI GUNASHEKARAN A R AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, R/AT FLAT NO.104, I FLOOR, 59. SRI SRIKANTH HALLA VENKATA NAGESWAR RAO A AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS, R/AT FLAT NO.302, 3RD FLOOR, 60. SRI VEGI SRINIVAS FATHERS NAME NOT KNOWN TO PLAINTIF AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, R/AT FLAT NO.404 4TH FLOOR, 61. SRI ANIL KUMAR ATNURKAR S/O SRI DINAKAR RAO ATNURKAR 36 YEARS, R/AT NO.304, 3RD FLOOR, 62. SRI S. LINGESH KUMAR S/O SRI M. SHIVA PERUMAL, MAJOR R/AT NO.201, 2ND FLOOR, 63. SRI JAYAKISHORE PAGADALA S/O SRI P VEERARAGHAVA RAO MAJOR R/AT NO.202 2ND FLOOR, 52 TO 63 IN THEIR RESPECTIVE FLATS AT MAHAVEER BOWER-II CMC KHATA NO.100, K T CHINNAPPANAHALLI, K R PURAM HOLBI BANGALORE EAST TALUK-560036.
64. DR. T N ACHAIAH S/O LATE SRI T M NANJAPPA 56 YEARS, R/A MAHIL SAMAJA ROAD, VIRAJPET-571 218 (KODAGU DT) 65. SMT CHENANDA NIRMALA MUDAPPA W/O LATE SRI C A MUDAPPA, 70 YEARS, R/A NO.228, 5TH CROSS ROAD, I MAIN ROAD, DOMLUR LAYOUT BANGALORE-560 071.
66. SRI P M ACHAIAH S/O SRI P R MUTHAPPA 36 YEARS, 67. SRI P G MUTHAPPA S/O SRI P A. GANAPATHI, 71 YEARS, 66 & 67 R/A 3367/5, 8TH CROSS 13TH MAIN, HAL II STAGE, BANGALORE-560 008.
68. M/S ROMA BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS A PARTNERSHIP FIRM HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO.858, 2ND MAIN ROAD, C BLOCK, AECS LAYOUT KUNDALAHALLI, BANGALORE-560 037.
REP BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER SMT. T R L PADMAVATHI 69. SRI MEDIDAM NAGAVENKATA CHANDRA MOHAN MAJOR, S/O VEERABHADRACHARAYALU R/AT FLAT NO.104, GROUND FLOOR, 70. SRI MAJETY SURAYANARAYANA MUTHY S/O SRI UPENDRA RAO, 38 YEARS, 71. SMT. GOKAVARAPU LAKSHMI NAGA VENKATA SARITHA, 32 YEARS, W/O SRI MAJETY SURYANARAYANA MURTHY 70 & 71 ARE R/A FLAT NO.204, I FLOOR, 72. SRI PALICHARLA SAREEN KUMAR REDDY S/O SRI P. VENUGOPALA REDDY MAJOR, FLAT NO.303, 3RD FLOOR 73. SRI. BACHUPALI AMARENDRA, S/O. SRI. B. CHALAPATHI RAO, MAJOR R/AT. NO.303, GROUND FLOOR, 74. SRI. RASOJU VEERABHADRACHARI S/O. SRI. ESHWARAIAH, MAJOR R/AT. NO.105, GROUND FLOOR 75. SMT. RADHA H. GOWDA W/O. LATE. SRI. HOMBE GOWDA, MAJOR, R/AT. NO.304,3RD FLOOR, 76. SRI. LINGA HARIKRISHNA PRASAD S/O. LATE. SRI. VENKATESWARA RAO, MAJOR, R/AT. FLAT.NO.203, 1ST FLOOR 69 TO 76 ARE ALL IN THEIR RESPECTIVE FLATS AT ROMA PEARL APARTMENTS SY NO.10/1, CHINNAPPANAHALLI VILLAGE, K R PURAM HOBLI, BANGALORE EAST TALUK-560036.
77. SRI. B.V. RADHAKRISHNA, S/O.LATE. SRI. MAHADEV BHAT, MAJOR, R/A: NO.562, AECS LAYOUT, KUNDALAHALLI, K.R.PURAM HOBLI,L BANGALORE SOUTH TALUK - 560036.
78. SRI. S.R. VENKATESH S/O.LATE. RAMESH, 46 YEARS R/A: NO.7, SOWMAY LAYOUT, KONENA AGRAHARA HAL POST, BANGALORE - 560017.
79. M/S. KEERTHANA CONSTRUCTIONS A PARTNERSHIP FIRM, HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO.1, ASSAYE ROAD, BANGALORE - 560042. REP. BY ITS PARTNERS 1. SMT. P. SARASWATHI, 2. SRI. B. CHIRANJEEVI, 3. SRI. P. MADHUSUDANA REDDY.
80. MAHAVEER PROPERTIES MAHAVEER BOWER-II, REP. BY ITS PROP: SRI. SATHYA SHEKAR, NO.1, MAHAVEER TOWERS, 3RD FLOOR, 24TH MAIN, JP NAGARA, 5TH PHASE, BANGALORE - 560078.
81. SRI JAYARAMA REDDY, S/O FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN TO PLAINTIFF, MAJOR, R/A : M.B.W. BRICK WIRES, CHANNAPPANA HALLI, MARATHHALLI POST, BANGALORE-560037.
SINCE DEAD BY LRS., 81(a) G.J. RAJA, MAJOR, S/O G. JAYARAMA REDDY, 81(b) G.J. VIJAYA KUMAR, MAJOR, S/O G. JAYARAMA REDDY, 81(c) G.J.ARUNA, MAJOR D/O G. JAYARAMA REDDY, 81(a) TO (c) ARE R/O M.B.W. BRICK WIRES, CHANNAPPANA HALLI, MARATHHALLI POST, BANGALORE-560037.
82. M/S GOLDEN GATE PROPERTIES LIMITED, A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE INDIAN COMPANIES ACT, HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT GOLDEN HOUSE, 820, 80 FEET ROAD, 8TH BLOCK, KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE-560 034.
DIRECTOR MR. C.D. SANJAY RAJ.
83. MRS. ANU CHOPRA (MAIDEN NAME MISS ARUNA B. RAO) W/O MR. RAJEEV CHOPRA, AGED 55 YEARS, NO.16/126, MAYUR APARTMENTS, PRABHAT COLONY, OP. HOTEL GALAXY, SANTA CRUZ EAST, MUMBAI-400055.
84. MR. GIRISH NAYUDU S/O LATE SRI A.V.R. NAYUDU, AGED 55 YEARS, RESIDING AT SITE NO. 10, AECS 1LAYOUT, A BLOCK, CHINNAPPANAHALLI VILLAGE, BANGALORE EAST TALUK 560036. BANGALORE.560036.
85. MRS. SHONALEE DAMODAR W/O SRI B.B. SUJITH CARIAPPA, R/A 351, 7TH MAIN, HAL 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560 008.
86. SRI CHAITANYA EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION REPRESENTED BY ITS FOUNDER DR. B.S. RAO., S/O FATHER'S NAME NOT KNOWN TO THE APPLICANT, MAJOR 87. DR. B. JANSI LAKSHMI BAI W/O B.S. RAO, SY. NO. 23, R.J. GARDENS, CHINNAPPANAHALLI, MARATHHALLI POST, BANGALORE-37.
88. M/S SHRIRAM BUILDERS, A REGISTERED PARTNERSHIP FIRM HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO. 10/1B, GRAPHITE INDIA ROAD, HOODI, BANGALORE-560 048.
REP. BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, SRI C. SURENDRANATH REDDY S/O LATE SRI. NARASIMHA REDDY.
89. T.N. BHAGYA W/O T.C. NAGARAJ AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, R/AT 274, 128, 13TH MAIN ROAD, HAL 2ND STAGE, BANGALORE-560 008.
90. M/S ICON DEVELOPERS, A REGISTERED PARTNERSHIP FIRM, (REGISTERED AS NO. SJN-F 744/2011-12), HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO. 106, 1ST FLOOR, ABOVE REKHA MARBLES, VIJAYA BANK COLONY EXTENSION, BANASAWADI RING ROAD, BANGALORE-43, REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNERS, MRS. C.SURENDRANATH REDDY, AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS, S/O LATE SRI C. NARASIMHA REDDY, MR. G. PRABHAKAR REDDY, AGED 52 YEARS S/O MR. GURIVI REDDY, SRI N. SRINIVASA REDDY, S/O LATE T. NARAYANA REDDY, 63 YEARS, R/AT NO. 89, 4TH CROSS, GOKULA 3RD STAGE, MYSORE-570002.
91. THE KARNATAKA INDUSTRIAL AREA DEVELOPMENT BOARD, NO.14/3, 2ND FLOOR, RESTROTHANA PARISHATH BUILDING, NRUPATUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE-560 001.
92. THE SPECIAL LAND ACUISITION OFFICER KARNATAKA INDUSTRIAL AREA DEVELOPMENT BOARD, NO.14/3, 2ND FLOOR, RASTROTHANA PARISHATH BUILDING, NRUPATHUNGA ROAD, BANGALORE-560 001.
93. M/S BANGALORE METRO RAIL CORPORATION HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT BMTC COMPLEX, 3RD FLOOR, K.H. ROAD,SHANTHI NAGAR, BANGALORE-560 027.
... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI G. S. PRASANNA KUMAR, ADVAOCATE FOR R24; NOTICE TO R1 TO R23 & R25 TO R93 IS DISPOSED WITH VIDE ORDER DATED 24.05.2018 ) … THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 24.04.2018 PASSED ON I.A.No.13/2017 IN O.S.No.1754/2006 PASSED BY THE XXII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL & SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND CONSEQUENTLY.
THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:
ORDER This writ petition is filed by the plaintiff against the impugned order passed by the trial Court dated 24.4.2018 on I.A.13/2017 in O.S.No.1754/2006.
2. The learned Counsel for the petitioner files a memo to the effect that in view of the subsequent development, the writ petition may be dismissed as not pressed.
3 . Placing the said memo on record, writ petition is dismissed as not pressed.
Sd/- Judge Nsu/-