IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU Dated this the 18TH day of November 2019 Before THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ALOK ARADHE Review Petition Nos.353-422/2019 & Review Petition Nos.445-455/2019 (In W.P. Nos.1885-1965/2019) BETWEEN:
1 ABHISHEK BAVALATTI, S/O VENKAPPA BAVALATTI, AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT V G BAVALATTI, PROGRAMME EXECUTIVE, ALL INDIA RADIO, RAICHUR-584103.
2 ANUPKUMAR L NAIK S/O LAXMIKANTH N NAIK, RESIDING AT VANASUMA NILAYA, KHB COLONY, PRABHATHNAGAR, HONNAVAR (UK) 581334.
3 SRINIVAS VAGDALE S/O MALLIKARJUN, AGED ABOUT D20 YEARS, RESIDING AT HOUSE NO. 9-6-33/1, "SAI SADAN" HANUMAN NAGAR, VIDYANAGAR, BIDAR-585403.
4 R REVATHI D/O R.RAVEENDRANATHA REDDY, AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, RESIDIGN AT H.NO:46-1-MH-3A, MARUTHI HOMES, JOHARAPURAM ROAD, A-CAMP, KURNOOL-518002.
5 M DIVYA, D/O MORTHALA PRABHAKAR, AGED ABOUT 19 YERAS, RESIDING AT HOUSE NO.6-2-2-5/3, BEHIND RAVALI NURSING HOME, HYDERAQBAD ROAD, BALAJINAGAR, JANGAON, DISTRICT-JANGAON, STATE-TELANGANA.
6 SUSHMITHA S AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, D/O SUDHAKAR S V, RESIDING AT LCC BUILDING, 3RD CROSS, KUVEMPU NAGAR, KOLAR-563101.
7 RIFATH UZMA S D/O SARTAJSABI R/AT MILATH CIRCLE, KOLAR.
8 SHILPASHRI D/O MR.MOHAN KRISHNA, R/AT 14/65 JAI SHANKAR COLONY, HOSUR, TAMILNADU-635 109 9 SHAFAQ NASEEM S/O MOHD. NASEEM KHAN R/AT 301, ABBASI UNIVERSAL COMPLEX OPP-REGISTRAR OFFICE, QAISERBAGH LUCKNOW-226001, UP 10 ZEBA KARNACHI D/O MOHAMMAD SHAFI KARNACHI R/AT #454, LIG, KHB COLONY, UDAYGIRI, SATTUR, DHARWAD-580009.
11 SRISHTI BAGALKOTI D/O SIDDAPPA BAGALKOTI R/AT PLOT NO.61, MATA PITRU KRUPA, KIADB LAYOUT, HALYAL ROAD, NEAR ASHOK GARDEN, DHARWAD-580003 12 AKSHARA U KARTHA D/O UPENDRAN KARTHA.G R/AT THOLALIL HOUSE, SRA 22, SASTHAMANGALAM ROAD, PERUMBAVOOR, P.O.ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, KERALA-683542 13 KSHAMA DIXIT D/O LALITHA DIXIT AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT NO.28/39 19TH MAIN, M C LAYOUT, VIJAYANAGAR, BANGALORE-560040 14 VIBHA N, D/O NAGESH PUTTAIAH, AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, DEVELOPMENT OFFICER LIC OF INDIA SOMWARPET-571236, KODAGU DIST 15 T P SONAL, D/O T R PRASHANTH, AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT KUNIGAL-572130 16 ARPITA PATIL D/O H SHIVA PRASANNA KUMAR AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT DOOR NO. 329 GS KRUPA TALUR ROAD, PARVATI NAGAR BELLARY -583 103 17 PRIYA R D/O R S HULAMANI AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT SECTOR NO.63A, PLATE NO.99, BRINDAVANA COLONY NEAR SATYABHUDARAYANA TEMPLE BAGALKOT-587 103 18 BHOOMIKA B N D/O NAGENDRA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT RAMESHWARANILAYA VIJAYANAGAR 1ST CROSS, HASSAN 19 GOURI PATIL D/O MALLIKARJUNAREDDY PATIL AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT FLAT NO.107 2ND FLOOR PALM MEADOWS APARTMENTS AMCO LAYOUT KODIGEHALLI ROAD, BANGALORE-560092 20 SNEHA KABADE D/O SHASHIKANT KABADE AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT CHANNABASAVESHAVAR COLONY BEHIND KALIDAS HIGH SCHOOL, ATHANI ROAD, BIJAPUR-586 101 21 RAKSHITHA G S D/O SHIVAPPA M G AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT SARASWATHINAGAR B BLOCK, DAVANAGERE-577 004 22 SUSHMITHA V D/O VENKATA NARAYANA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT # 6 SHRI SIDDHI GROUND FLOOR 8TH MAIN ROAD, BALAJI LAYOUT, TATA NAGAR KODIGEHALLI -560092 23 N D POORNAJITA D/O E NATARAJAN AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, RESIDING AT FLAT NO.1D HVS HOMES-4, 16TH CROSS MALLESHWARAM, BANGALORE-55 24 SAHANA D/O CHANDRSHEKAR SULTANPUR AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT # 255 9TH CROSS BAPUJI LAYOUT CHANDRA LAYOUT BANGALORE 25 MOULYA V SHETTY D/O VIJAY KUMAR SHETTY AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, RESIDING AT OM SHREE DHAMA # 23 KPA BLOCK CHANDRALAYOUT VIJAYANAGAR BANGALORE-560040 26 P AMITHA REDDY D/O CHADNRA SEKAR REDDY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT SECOND FLOOR BAIRAGIPATTEDA TIRUPATI ANDHRA PRADESH-517501 27 DADABEE H D/O SHAIK SHAVALI H AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, RESIDING AT S/O CHANDASAB H 6TH WARD MANSUR MAZID NEAR TEKKALAKOTE-583122 SIRUGUPPA (TQ) BELLARY (DISTRICT) 28 K AKARSHA D/O KOLGANI SRINIVAS AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, RESIDING AT 7-6-184, KAPUWADA HANMAKONDA DIST WARRANGAL TELANGANA-506 001 29 PRIYA ASHOK D/O ASHOK KUMAR PILLAI AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT FLAT NO 301, ROCK HEIGHTS 13TH CROSS, KAGGADASAPURA C V RAMAN NAGAR BANGALORE – 93 30 LINNY WILSON D/O WILSON MOLEYIL POWLOUS AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT NO 79 , 3RD MAIN 3RD CROSS, M P M LAYOUT NAGARABHAVI 2ND STAGE BANGALORE 56 31 SUSHMA J AYLI D/O JAMBANNA S AYLI AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, RESIDING AT JAYANAGAR 2ND STAGE, 1ST CROSS, GANGAVATHI KOPPAL DISTRICT – 583227 32 ANAGHA P G D/O COL GANGADHARAN M AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT NO E030 WISTERIA BRIGADE MEADOWS KANAKAPURA ROAD, KAGLIPURA BANGALORE – 560082 33 MITHILA SHETTY D/O JAYAPRAKASH SHETTY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT THENE SARVAPRAKASH NAGAR, ANKADAKATTE KOTESHWARA KUNDAPUR TALUK UDUPI 34 RAKASHITHA M D/O MUNIGANGAIAH AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, RESIDING AT BYRAWESHWARA NILAYA COURT ROAD, VINAYAK NAGAR DODDABALLAPUR TOWN – 561203 35 SANCHITHA SHENOY D/O PRAKASH SHENOY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT SHENOY NIVAS POST: HALASINAKATTE PILAR VILLAGE UDUPI TQ & DIST 36 VARSHA C S D/O CHIKKA SUBBA REDDY AGED 21 YEARS RESIDING AT 30 FEET ROAD, RAJIV NAGAR, PRABHAKAR LAYOUT, CHINTAMANI – 563112 37 PRATYUSHA D P K D/O VENKATA RAMANA D V AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT # 335BM, 3RD D MAIN, 6TH A CROSS, R R LAYOUT NAGADEVANAHALLI, BANGALORE – 560056 38 ANANTHA SRILALITA BULUSU S/O SATYA PRASAD BULUSU AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT H-M08 HABITAT SPLENDOUR ITPL ROAD KUNDANAHALLI NEAR CMRIT BANGALORE – 560037 39 AKHILA TADAVARTHY D/O VIJAYAKUMAR AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT 5-29-10/ BUJJAJ SAHEB STREET 23RD WARD, REPALLE- 522265 40 SAISURYA MOUNICA D/O MOHAN AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS, RESIDING AT R-42 RAMALAYAM ROAD, KOPPARRU, NARASAPURA MANDEL WEST GODAVARI DIST-523 264 ANDHRA PRADESH 41 JOHN PAUL S .O. ADV. PAUL M P AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT MECHERY HOUSE, BAZAR ROAD, PUDUKAD P O THRISSUR - 680301 KERALA 42 ZAINUL ABID PARENT: ABUBAKER AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS, RESIDING AT KALAMULLATHIL HOUSE, PONMERIPARAMBIL POST, VADAKARA CALICUT- 673542 KERALA 43 LAVANYA B V D/O VIJAY KUMAR A AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS RESIDING AT C/O HANUMANTHRAJU # 301, 3RD FLOOR, RAGHAVA RESIDENCY 3RD CROSS, VYALIKAVALA LAYOUT, VIJAYANAGAR, KARNATAKA – 560040 44 PRIYA AKKI D/O VIRUPAKSHI R AKKI AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT BIJJARAGI BIJAPUR 45 PUSHPA P M AGED AVBOUT 21 YEARS D/O PURANDAR MURAGOJI TQ: RAI BAG DIST BELGAUM A/P HIDKAL PINCODE: 591220 46 POORNIMA S HALYAL AGE: 20 FATHERS NAME SANGAPPA HALYAL ADDRESS MATRU KRUPA NGO COLONY KINNAL ROAD KOPPAL PIN CODE: 583231 47 ANUJA GUPTA S/O SATYAPRAKASH GUPTA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT HIG -663 ARVIND VIHAR BAGMUGALIA MPHB COLONY BHOPAL – 462043 48 Y S VAISHNAVI D/O K S ARUNA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT D NO 28, 2ND MAIN, 7TH CROSS, CHAMRAJPET BANGALORE – 560018 49 K CHANDANA PRIYA D/O K NAGARAJU AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT FLAT NO 511 RAJAHAMSA KINGDOM APARTMENT RAMACHANDRA NAGAR ANANTAPUR ANDHRA PRADESH – 515001 50 MOHAMMED FAIZ S/O NASIR KHAN RASHEEDY AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS RESIDING AT # 63, 9TH A MAIN, 4TH CROSS, BTM LAYOUT, 1ST STAGE OPPOSITE TO SHIFAA MEDICALS BANGALORE 51 SANJAN M S/O K.L.MANJAPPA, RESIDING AT BANASHANKARI NILAYA, NIJALINGAPPA SCHOOL ROAD, HOSADURGA CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 52 GURURAJ BENNUR S/O VENUGOPAL BENNUR AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS R/AT KARATAGI 583229 (POST & TQ), KOPPAL (DIST) 53 KARTHIK S S/O SURESH HANCHATE AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS R/AT #30, SRINIVAS NILAYA, SRINIVAS NAGAR, S R MATH, OLD HUBLI, HUBLI 580024.
54 VIRAJA B C D/O BADRINATH C P AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS R/AT NO.784, MADHAVA NILAYA, 13TH MAIN 42ND CROSS, 3RD BLOCK, RAJAJINAGAR, BANGALORE 560010.
55 V ABITHA D/O M VENKATESAN AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS R/AT 4/5, 3RD STREET, TANSI NAGAR VELACHERY CHENNAI 600042.
56 VARSHA S KUMAR D/O SHIAKUMAR AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS R/AT FLAT NO 208, MANGAM ELITE APARTMENTS, 19TH MAIN HSR LAYOUT, SECTOR 2, BANGALORE 560102.
57 SINDU C D/O CHANNEGOWDA AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS R/AT 2ND CROSS, DR. LOHIA ROAD, VIDYA NAGAR HASSAN 573201.
58 VISHAKHA KESHAVA PRASAD S/O DR KESHAV PRASAD & DR RUDRAMMAJI AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS R/AT FLAT NO.4B, TOWER 2, ROSEDALE GARDEN COMPLEX, ACTION AREA 3, NEW TOWN, KOLKATA 700156.
59 TANZEELA FIRDOSE HUNCHAYAL D/O MOHAMAD NAYIM HUNCHAYAL RESIDING AT 233, T F HOUSE, BCC LAYOUT, 2ND STAGE CHANDRA LAYOUT, BANGALORE-560040 60 SREEHARI R VIJAY, S/O DR C R VIJAY RESIDING AT NO.491, 16TH CROSS, A-1 BLOCK, VIJAYANAGAR 3RD STAGE, MYSORE 61 LALINI PRIYA, D/O EAMMANUEL MOHARE RESIDING AT NO.49/52, BAUXITE ROAD, ANNAPURNAWADI AZAMNAGAR, BELGAUM 62 RAMYA RAVINDRA PATIL D/O RAVINDRA A PATIL RESIDING AT NO.450, 1ST FLOOR, 8TH MAIN , T R SUBBARAO ROAD, HANUMANTHNAGAR, BANGALORE-560019 63 AKSHATHA M., D/O SRIDHAR BHAT M RESIDING AT NO.49, SRI KRISHNA NILAYA 4TH MAIN, 2ND CROSS, SIDDHIVINAYAKA LAYOUT KODIGEHALLI , BANGALORE-560097 64 SPOORTHI P D/O DR PRASAD MURTHY RESIDING AT NO.105, VIVEKANANDA BLOCK, TEACHERS LAYOUT MYSURU-570029 65 LEKHA K S D/O DR SREENIVAS K S RESIDING AT NO.295, SRILAKSHMI, 1ST CROSS, RAVINDRANAGAR, SHIVAMOGGA-577201 66 SHIVANI M R., D/O MEGHARAJ K., RESIDING AT NO.430, 8TH MAIN 4TH CROSS, HANUMANTHNAGAR BANGALORE-560019 67 JYOTHI AMITA D/O JYOTHI VAIJINATH RESIDING AT # 9-8-375 JYOTI NIVAS BASAWANAGAR BVB COLLEGE, GANDHI GUNJ, BIDAR-585403 68 SWATHI S D/O SUDARSHAN K B RESIDING AT SWATHI 2ND BLOCK 2ND MAIN PARK ROAD KUVEMPUNAGAR, TUMKUR -572103 69 UDAYA M, S/O MADEVA, RESIDING AT CHIKKALATHURU VILLAGE, DODDALATHURU POST KOLLEGALA TALUK, CH NAGAR-571444 70 MEGHA SHRAVYA CHATRADHI D/O NAGA SRINIVAS CHATRADHI RESIDING AT JANGAMARA KALGUDI GANGAVATHI , KOPPAL. …PETITIONERS (BY SRI. AJIT ANAND SHETTY, ADVOCATE) A N D :
1. UNION OF INDIA BY MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE, 7-B MOTI LAL NEHRU MARG, NEW DELHI BY ITS SECRETARY-110011 2. MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA POCKET-14, SECTOR-8, DWARKA PHASE-1 NEW DELHI-110077, INDIA BY ITS REGISTRAR/SECRETARY 3. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY THE DEPARTMENT OF MEDICAL EDUCATION DIRETORATE OF MEDICAL EDUCATION ANAND RAO CIRCLE, BANGALORE-560009 KARNATAKA, INDIA BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY 4. RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES, 4TH T BLOCK, 4TH T BLOCK EAST, PATTABHIRAMA NAGAR, JAYANAGAR BENGALURU, KARNATAKA 560041 BY ITS REGISTRAR 5. SAMBHRAM INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES AND RESEARCH D.K.PLANTATION, BEML NAGAR, KOLAR GOLD FIELDS, KARNATAKA-563115 BY ITS SECRETARY ...RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. H.MALLAN GOUD, CGSC FOR R1 SRI. N.K.RAMESH, ADVOCATE FOR R4 SRI. K.DIWAKARA, ADVOCATE FOR R5 SRI. KIRAN KUMAR, HCGP FOR R3) These review petitions are filed under Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 of the CPC praying this Hon’ble Court to review the order dated 22nd August 2019 passed in Writ Petition Nos.1885-1965/2019 in as much as directing the 1st respondent Union of India to constitute a committee comprising a senior officer from the Central Bureau of Investigation and two doctors of repute from the All India Institute of Medical sciences or any other premier medical institution to inspect the facilities of the 6th respondent institution and inter-alia verify if such facility, including the teaching faculty, patient inflow and other clinical facilities are adequate to train the petitioners herein to graduate as qualified medical practitioners in terms of the ruling of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of “Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan University and another Vs. Union of India and others” reported in 2019(1)SCALE 700; and etc.
These review petitions coming on for Hearing on Orders at Dharwad Bench, through video conference, this day, the Court made the following:
ORDER Sri Ajith Anand Shetty, learned counsel for the petitioners.
2. Sri H.Mallan Goud, learned CGC for R1, Sri N.K.Ramesh, learned counsel for R4, Sri K.Diwakara, learned counsel for R5, Sri Kiran Kumar, learned HCGP for R3.
3. For the reasons assigned by this Court in the order passed today in R.P. Nos.341-343/2019 & R.P. Nos.441-444/2019, these review petitions also stand disposed of in terms of the order passed in the aforesaid review petitions.
Sd/- JUDGE Kms