IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA KALABURAGI BENCH DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF MARCH, 2019 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.BAJANTHRI W.P.Nos.8409-8436/2019 (EDN-RES) BETWEEN:
1. VARUN KUMAR GADDI AGED 19 YEARS S/O AMARESH GADDI R/O H NO.1-867/16 NEAR SHIVA TEMPLE VENKATESHNAGAR OLD JEWARGI ROAD KALABURAGI-585 102 2. VAISHNAVI V WADEKAR AGED 19 YEARS D/O VENKATESH WADEKAR H NO.5-104 SHAHABAZAR NAKA KATAGARPURA KALABURAGI-585 101 3. ABANNI BASANTH REDDY D/O A BALREDDY AGED 19 YEARS GULBARGA APARTMENT VASTHSYALA HOSPITAL BACK SIDE NEAR RTO OFFICE KALABURAGI-585 101 4. AKARAPU AJAYSHANKAR S/O AKARAPU SURESHKUMAR AGED 21 YEARS OLD RTO, H NO.PLOT NO.55 OPP.GULBARGA APARTMENTS KALABURAGI-585 101 5. AKSHATHA D/O ANILKUMAR DANGE AGED 19 YEARS AT POST, SYED CHINCHOLI KALABURAGI-585 104 5. CHEKKA SRIVATSAV S/O CHEKKA NAGESWARA RAO AGED 20 YEARS ADARSHNAGAR NEAR BASAWESHWARA HOSPITAL KALABURAGI-585 105 7. C SRIKANTH S/O C VENKAPPA AGED 19 YEARS NEAR KHARGE PETROL PUMP JAYANAGAR KALABURAGI-585 105 8. SYED ABUSALEHA S/O SYED ALIJAN AGED 19 YEARS NEAR KHARGE PETROL PUMP JAYANAGAR. KALABURUGI-585 105 9. VISHNUPRIYA D/O LINGANGOUDA AGED 19 YEARS R/O CHANDRASHEKARSHETTY BUILDING FLAT NO.27 VISHWASHWARAYA COLONY SEDAM ROAD KALABURAGI-585 102 10. ASHISH KELVIN S/O RAVIKUMAR AGED 21 YEARS #5-6-80, HOLSTON HOSPITAL QUARTERS HYDERABAD ROAD YADAGIRI-585 202 11. VISHWASHREE D/O PRABHUDEVREDDY, AGE: 19 YEARS V G WOMENS HOSTEL BEHIND ASIAN MALL, KALABURAGI-585 105 12. BHAVANA SANNATHI D/O SHAMRAYA GOUDA AGE: 21 YEARS BASAWESHWARA COLONY 4TH CROSS,M B NAGAR KALABURAGI-585 105 13. K TABITA NEELANJANI D/O K R PRASAD AGE: 19 YEARS V G WOMENS HOSTEL BEHIND ASIAN MALL KALABURAGI-585 105 14. SANDESH S SHINDE S/O SUBHASH SHINDE AGE: 20 YEARS # 2-910/67/415 SWASTIKNAGAR KALABURAGI-585 105 15. SHIVALINGANNA S K S/O SIDDANNA AGE: 20 YEARS GUBBI COLONY BEHIND SS SIGNUR COLLEGE BILGUNDI HOUSE KALABURAGI-585 105 16. SACHINKUMAR S/O GURULINGAPPA AGE: 20 YEARS OPP.BHEEMALLI PETROL PUMP, BESIDE SAROJINI MODI HOSPITAL, KALABURAGI-585 105 17. BRUNDA S PARAMESHWAR D/O SHARANABASAPPA, AGE: 20 YEARS # 1-891/75/126 BRUNDAVANA NILAYA KARUNESHWARNAGAR KALABURAGI-585 102 18. G SAICHARAN AKSHAY KUMAR S/O MALLIKARJUN KALSHATTY AGE: 21 YEARS JAGAT CIRCLE BEHIND SHARADA MALL GAZIPURA KALABURAGI-585 101 19. G AKSHAY KUMAR S/O G KISHAN RAO, AGE: 21 YEARS NEAR KHARGE PETROL PUMP JAYANAGAR, KALABURUGI-585 105 20. GEETA S B D/O SHARANABASAPPA B B AGE: 19 YEARS # 9-587/103/1/71 J R NAGAR, ALAND ROAD, KALABURAGI-585 101 21. LUBNA AZIZ D/O MOHD.AZIZ PATEL AGED 22 YEARS, # 85 BEHIND TINY PEARLS SCHOOL KHAZA COLONY KALABURAGI-585104 22. M MOUNIKA D/O VENKATAYYA AGED 21 YEARS, # 19 RANGDAL GUEST HOUSE GUBBI COLONY KALABURGI -585 105 23. PRIYANKA L ALLURKAR D/O LINGANNA ALLURKAR AGED 20 YEARS C# 9-104, SHAHABAZARNAKA KATAGARPURA KALABURGI-585 101 24. KHAN RUKIYA BEGUM IBRAHIM D/O KHAN IBRAHIM AGED 21 YEARS, D/O KHAN IBRAHIM V G WOMENS HOSTEL BEHIND ASIAN MALL KALABURGI -585 105 25. SEEMA S M D/O SHIVASHARANAPPA MUDBOOL AGED 22 YEARS SANTHOSH COLONY UDNOOR DOUBLE ROAD, BESIDE JAYATHREETH KLAYANAMANTAP KALABURAGI-585 105 26. SHAH FAISAL S/O ABDUL MAJEED TAMBOLI AGED 22 YEARS 1ST FLOOR RAJ BUILDING JEWARGI ROAD, KALABURAGI-585 102 27. SRINIVAS S/O NAGAPPA APPARAW AGED 19 YEARS H NO.2-141 JAGAT KOTNOOR DARWESH KALABURAGI-585 102 28. N RAMAKANTH REDDY S/O N SARVESHWARA REDDY AGED 21 YEARS SWASTIKNAGAR, OPP. BILGUNDI LAYOUT, SEDAM ROAD KALABURAGI – 585 101 (BY SMT DIVYATEJ H.N., ADVOCATE) AND:
1. RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES ... PETITIONERS REPRESENTED BY ITS VICE-CHANCELLOR /REGISTRAR 4TH BLOCK EAST, PATTABHIRAMANGAR JAYANAGAR BENGALURU-560041 2. CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY JAWAHARLAL NEHRU BHARATHIYA CHIKITSA AVUM HOMOEOPATHIC ANUSUNDHAM BHAVAN 61-65 INSTITUTIONAL AREA OPP D BLOCK, JANAKPURI NEW DELHI-110058 3. THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY MINISTRY OF AYUSH AYUSH BHAVAN B-BLOCK, G.P.O. COMPLEX, INA NEW DELHI-110023 4. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF AYUSH VIDHAN SOUDHA BENGALURU – 560 001 ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI K.M. GHATE AGA FOR R4;
SRI R.J. BHUSARE, ADVOCATE FOR R1, NOTICE TO OTHER RESPONDENTS DISPENSED WITH VIDE ORDER DATED 13.03.2019) THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO GRANT OR EXTEND RELIEFS WHICH WERE GRANTED IN W.P.NOS. 55322/2018 & 55987/2018 (KARUNAKAR H N & ANOTHER VS. RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES & OTHERS) TO THE PETITIONERS SINCE THE FACT MATRIX OF THIS WRIT PETITION MATCHES WITH THAT OF W.P.NOS.55322/2018 & 55987/2018 (EDN-RES) AS PER JUDGMENT ANNEXURE-E.
THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:
ORDER Learned Additional Government Advocate accepts notice for respondent No.4. Sri R.J.Bhusare, learned counsel accepts notice for respondent No.1. Notice to other respondents is dispensed with.
2. Petitioners have sought for the relief to grant or extend reliefs which were granted in W.P.Nos.55322/2018 and 55987/2018 (Karunakar H.N & Another vs Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences and Others) to the petitioners since the fact matrix of this Writ Petition matches with that of W.P.Nos.55322/2018 and 55987/2018 (EDN-RES).
3. Petitioners have rushed to this court seeking the aforesaid relief without there being demand before the appropriate respondent.
4. Hence, petitioners have not made out a case.
Accordingly, petitions stand dismissed. Reserving liberty to the petitioners to approach concerned respondent by way of a detailed representation while contending that their grievance is on par with the decision in the case of Karunakar H.N and another Vs. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences and Others passed in W.P.No.55522/2018 and 55987/2018.
5. In the event of such representation submitted to the concerned respondent and the concerned respondent is hereby directed to entertain the petitioners grievance and pass order whether their grievance is on par with Karunakar’s case or not.
6. The above exercise shall be completed within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of petitioners application.
Sd/- JUDGE sn